Seti Astro Suite Pro; A relatively new image processing suite for astrophotographers

Seti Astro Suite Pro

A different and relatively new image processing suite for astrophotographers

Official SASP logo

Link to the SASP website

Until recently the main goto software for image processing have been Deep Sky Stacker, Siril, PixInsight, Sequator, AstroSurface, Astro Pixel Processor, Astronomy tools, Autostakkert!, Affinity Photo and a handful of lesser known programs. These range from expensive paid-for software, to freeware-donationware. Some, such as Sequator and Autostakkert! are mainly stacking software, whilst others have various post stacking capabilities. For a variety of reasons, financial among them, each program has its own following of loyal users.

Seti Astro Suite Pro (SASP)

SASP is being developed at a prodigious rate with a couple of versions being released in a week being quite common. At the time of writing the version is 1.3.18

SASP runs on Windows, Linux, MacOS x86-64 and Apple silicon.

Seti Astro Suite Pro is developed by Franklin Marek. It is written in Python with Qt6 and is open source donationware. SASP grew out of Seti Astro Suite, its predecessor, as more advanced functionality was added. 

SASP has comprehensive functionality and has integrated GraXpert and Starnet++ functionality as long as the software is present and the binaries are available. SASP also has integrated Aberration Correction (AI) and Franklin Marek’s own software; the Cosmic Clarity suite plus other processes.

Rather than list the processes available we shall use a series of screenshots showing the drop down menus that give access to the various processes.

One process that sets SASP apart from other image processing software is that it offers Multi-Frame Deconvolution Stacking (Image MM) in addition to offering regular stacking.

Multi‑Frame Blind Deconvolution has been developed by a mix of international academic research groups, national observatories and institutes, defence laboratories, and industry teams collaborating to develop algorithms into high‑performance systems.

Image MM works in a completely different way to regular stacking and so in SASP provides choice in how a final stacked image is produced.

Multi-Frame Deconvolution (Multi-Frame Blind Deconvolution (MFBD)) is a class of image-restoration methods that jointly estimate a single high‑quality latent image and the set of blurring kernels (point‑spread functions, PSFs) that produced a sequence of separately blurred frames, then combine that information to produce a single de-blurred, higher‑signal image.

Regular stacking (alignment and ‘averaging’) improves signal‑to‑noise ratio by summing information but does not remove blur introduced by the PSF. SNR (Signal to Noise ratio) improves as √(n) where n = the number of frames stacked, but resolution stays limited by the worst blur.

Multi-Frame deconvolution explicitly models and removes the blur by estimating PSFs and inverting the convolution process, recovering higher spatial frequencies and therefore improving effective resolution in addition to SNR.

Regular stacking assumes the object is unchanged and that noise/statistical rejects are the main issues.

MFBD leverages frame‑to‑frame PSF diversity as information, so it can recover detail lost to variable blur.

PSF estimation per frame measures  PSFs  or estimates them blindly within the optimisation loop.

Iterative reconstruction alternates updates of the latent image and the PSFs until convergence, using regularisation to avoid noise amplification.

Final combination output is a single deconvolved image with improved resolution and SNR compared with any single frame or a simple ‘average’ stack.

Some stages in the Muti-Frame Deconvolution Stacking of a group of images

The final Image MM stacked image loaded into SASP for further processing

SASP offers regular stacking with Drizzle if required. This is computationally less demanding than Multi-Frame Deconvolution Stacking and executes quicker, particularly if GPU hardware acceleration is not available on the users computer. Multi-Frame Deconvolution may not execute properly if a non NVIDIA GPU or GPU co-processor such as RADEON graphics is present. However, it is possible to set the stacking suite not to use hardware acceleration and stacking then works, albeit without the speed advantage of hardware acceleration.

We have tested this successfully on 7 computers with various operating systems and SOCs. and found the speed without hardware acceleration to be quite acceptable.

It is clear that Seti Astro Suite Pro is set to be one of the main contenders in the league of astronomical stacking and image processing software.

The Seti Astro Suite Pro website can be accessed by using the link under the SASP logo at the top of this page, or click HERE.

  

Folded optics in refractors

The majority of refracting telescopes have straight through optics and the physical length of the telescope is dependent on the focal length. This helps when the objective lens is acromatic rather than apochromatic. With an acromatic objective, the red and blue light are brought to the ‘same’ focus whereas with an apochromatic objective all red blue and green light are brought to the ‘same’ focus, reducing or even eliminating chromatic aberration. With a long focal length, an acromat brings the different wavelengths of light to a closer focus than with a short focal length. 

Other types of telescopes such as Schmidt Cassegrains, Maksutov Cassegrains and a number of other types of telescopes use folded optics to shorten the physical length of a scope of long focal length. There are some folded optics design telescopes that are not intended to have an eyepiece, but which are designed to have a camera at the position normally occupied by the secondary mirror in say, a Schmidt Cassegrain. Such a scope is the recent Sky-Watcher HAC125 DX Minigraph which is very fast at f/2 and F=250mm and is very suitable for Electronically Assisted Astronomy, EAA.

However, we are dealing here with a class of refractors that have folded optics and we shall use 4 examples:

Example 1

The most familiar example of folded optics refractors is Porro prism binoculars.

The folded optics using Porro prisms shortens the length of the binoculars as well as placing the objectives further apart, enhancing the 3D viewing experience.

Although historically there have been a number of folded optics telescope made by scope manufacturers such as Unitron and amateur astronomers such as Dave Trott, we shall only look at a selected few:

Example 2

The Zerochromat Refracting Telescope

Peter Wise, from Pensarn, Conwy, Wales, UK, designed and made the 10" Zerochromat Refracting Telescope for the Custer Institute and Observatory in Long Island, New York State. It is Located in the main observatory dome and is the largest of its kind in the United States. Designed by award-winning optician Peter Wise and manufactured in Pensarn. Its dialyte lenses make it apochromatic. A dialyte lens is a compound optical lens where the individual lens elements are separated by a significant air space, allowing for the correction of optical aberrations like chromatic aberration. This air-spaced design offers more "refractive surfaces" for correcting distortions. 

Peter Wise demonstrating his 8" Zerochromat folded optics refractor to the Swansea Astronomical Society meeting in Swansea University, UK on March 14, 2014.

Some of Peter Wise's publications:

The Dialyte refractor revisited. Journal of the British Astronomical Association. vol.127, 6, p.350-353, 2017

The retrofocally corrected apochromatic dialyte refracting telescope Wall, J. & Wise, P.  Journal of the British Astronomical Association, vol.117, 1, p.29-34, 2007

Example 3

This example is a beautiful folded optics refractor made by Berger Astrogeräte. 

https://www.astrogeraete.de/

The mechanical part was made and designed by Andreas Berger. The optical path was designed by Dr. Georg Dittié. Georg Dittié is the programmer of the program "Giotto".

The photographs of the telescope were provided by Andreas Berger.

One side removed to show the folded optics with the objective, two reflecting mirrors and the eyepiece holder.

This telescope is of a very compact design and demonstrates how it is possible to build a refractor into a small space by the use of folded optics.

Example 4

The Seestar S50 smart telescope by ZWO

The telescope is controlled by the Seestar app on an Android tablet/phone; or an iPad/iPhone.

It has a 50mm objective and a focal length of 250mm. The camera sensor is a Sony IMX462. This produces an image with a field of view of 0.73° x 1.29°.

The Seestar S50 in AZ mode

The Seestar S50 in EQ mode

Zwo have not published schematics for the Seestar but the closest they come is a promotional image representing the interior with an exploded view of the apochromatic triplet objective. This picture is derived from that image:

The folded optics are clearly visible showing the light rays converging and being reflected onto the camera sensor. The folded optics are the reason why Seestars are such compact telescopes. The design, whilst not being directly related, is very reminiscent of Andreas Berger's telescope.

It would be very interesting to see astronomical images produced by folded optics refractors other than the smart telescopes.

Further use of AstroEdit on Seestar stacked and saved results

Workflow processing an image downloaded to the Seestar S30-controlling iPad upon termination of 62 minutes of live-stacking:

Click on an image to get a closer view

The image loaded int AstroEdit has the watermark at the bottom which needs to be cropped out. This is why it may be better to set the Seestar not to save with a watermark

The image is set for cropping

The watermark is cropped out

The cropped image ready for processing

Removing the stars

The removed stars

Contrast increased on the starless image

The stars put back into the image

The stars reduced in AI mode (maybe a bit too much but to emphasize the effect)

The Original image

The processed image

A blink comparison of the original and processed images

There are more things that could have been done to the image, but this simply illustrates some of the things that are possible with AstroEdit in iOS.

Steve Wainwright

Using AstroEdit on iOS to process Seestar images

AstroEdit is an application that runs on iOS but unfortunately not on Android. It is a low cost application obtainable from the iOS App Store for £2.99.

We shall discuss the using of AstroEdit on iOS to process Seestar images downloaded to your iPad (or iPhone) when live-stacking is terminated. It is also possible to apply AI de-noising (which also seems to reduce or eliminate gradients) before live-stacking is terminated the de-noised image can be downloaded to the iPad. If you have access to an iPad but have used an Android tablet to control the Seestar, it is possible to get the downloaded images over to the iPad by sharing them to Google photos in the cloud.

It is conventional wisdom that all processing should be done while the image is at a high bit depth (32 bits or sometimes 16 bits). However, as long as no compression has been used, it is still possible to do quite a lot with an 8 bit image. In the case of the downloaded images from the live-stacking, quite a lot has already been done. The live-stacking software has constrained the image to the dimensions and composition of the first downloaded image. It has also increased the brightness and reduced the noise. If it has also been AI de-noised it is ready for further gentle processing. This is where AstroEdit comes in. Although AstroEdit can download 16 bit images, they are turned immediately into 8 bit with which the software can do very little. AstroEdit requires exactly the sort of images that are downloaded to the iPhone or iPad after live-stacking in the Seestar is terminated.

The big difference between further processing the downloaded Seestar images in any software such as Google Photos or Photos on the iPad. Is that these programs can brighten up and increase the saturation of the images etc. but doing this to the whole image, which makes the stars even brighter as well as the nebulosity. AstroEdit can remove gradients if still present, but then it can remove and keep the stars. This leaves the starless image to be further enhanced without touching the stars. Then the stars can be added back in their original state to produce a much improved image.

Here is a work-flow on a Seestar S30 36 minutes live-stacked image if IC1805 the Heart nebula that had been IA de-noised.

The original downloaded image of IC1805

In this case the Seestar has been set to watermark the image. However, this does spoil the bottom of the image. It may be nice to see the information there, but from an imaging point of view, it is best to set the Seestar not to watermark the image so that the whole of the image is available for further processing. In this case, the image will require cropping.

The image loaded into AstroEdit

Setting up for cropping in AstroEdit

The image cropped in AstroEdit

The cropped image ready for further processing in AstroEdit

The stars removed in AstroEdit

The Stars image

The starless image enhance by some of the controls visible

The original stars added back

The saved, processed final image

A final observation on another AstroEdit AI function called 'Oval'.

The purpose of this function is to correct deformed stars. I previously published a blog article on the use of the online StarFix program to correct the deformed stars that were produced by a faulty Seestar S30 that I had to return because of it's misaligned optical train.

The faulty image that I used in that article was this image of M17

Clicking on the image will reveal the badly distorted stars

When this image was loaded into AstroEdit and the AI function 'Oval' was set to maximum, this was the result:

The star shapes were considerable improved and so this software could be useful to someone who might have a Seestar with badly aligned optics causing star deformations

In conclusion, AstroEdit is a program that should be in the arsenal of any Seestar user who has access to an iOS device.

More lesser known nebulae

Provocatio est invenire obiecta caelestia innominata.

 Nebula in Cygnus in the region of the star HIP100144 

1 hour 30 minutes worth of 5 min exposures captured of an un-named nebula in the region of the star HIP100144 in Cygnus by AstroDMx Capture through an Altair 60mm ED refractor with an 0.8 flattener/reducer and an Altair Ha/OIII dualband filter. Stacked and partly processed in PixInsight , further processed in GraXpert, SetiAstroSuite and Gimp.

    

Nebula in Lacerta in the region of the star HD213976

1 hour 30 minutes worth of 5 min exposures captured of an un-named nebula in the region of the star HD213976 in Lacerta by AstroDMx Capture through an Altair 60mm ED refractor with an 0.8 flattener/reducer and an Altair Ha/OIII dualband filter. Stacked and partly processed in PixInsight , further processed in GraXpert, SetiAstroSuite, Gimp, G'MIC and Starnet++

Nebula in Cygnus in the region of the star HD203663 SH2-114, LBN-347 The Flying dragon nebula.

1 hour 30 minutes worth of 5 min exposures captured of an un-named nebula in the region of the star HD203663 in Cygnus by AstroDMx Capture through an Altair 60mm ED refractor with an 0.8 flattener/reducer and an Altair Ha/OIII dualband filter. Stacked and partly processed in PixInsight , further processed in GraXpert and Gimp.

Nebula in Scutum in the region of the star HD168112

1 hour 30 minutes worth of 5 min exposures captured of an un-named nebula in the region of the star HD168112 in Scutum by AstroDMx Capture through an Altair 60mm ED refractor with an 0.8 flattener/reducer and an Altair Ha/OIII dualband filter. Stacked and partly processed in PixInsight , further processed in GraXpert, SetiAstroSuite, Gimp, G'MIC and Starnet++

The lesser known nebulae are varied and beautiful objects  that make a diverting challenge while Nicola continues with the porting of AstroDMx Capture over to Qt6 along with the concomitant refactoring.